For the last couple of months, we’ve seen considerable growth on Hoptoad accounts and traffic. Thank you all! But this introduced new traffic patterns and challenges. During this time we’ve been mostly keeping up with this growth and making sure we can provide as reliable a service as possible. There have been some bumps along the way. This is what has happened, what we’ve done about it, and what is yet to come.
For over a year, Hoptoad has stored exception details as a gzipped XML on Amazon S3. When an error is POSTed to our API endpoint, we validate it, group it with similar errors, and store it on the app server’s file system. Every five minutes there was a cron job that would upload all these XML files to S3. These details were only available for viewing on the UI after they made it to S3. This is why, more often than we had liked, you would see the dreaded message “Details for this error are still being processed”. This served us well for some time, but we knew it was time to rethink this architecture.
There were many problems with this approach. The most obvious was that this “still processing” error was becoming more and more common, and this degraded the experience of viewing error messages for our users (us included). The first thing we did to improve that experience was rather simple and did not require wholesome architectural changes: Instead of trying to display the last notice that we got for that error group, we showed you the last processed error for that group. So therefore, instead of seeing the processing message, you would see actionable data for that exception so that you can get back to work fixing bugs.
Even though this helped the situation and the number of support requests greatly decreased, we always knew this was a temporary solution and we could do better. We needed a way to store error details in the life cycle of the request, in such a way that it was available immediately afterwards for viewing. Uploading to S3 became too slow for our needs.
Furthermore, this was not the only problem with this architecture. The larger problem is that because of our high traffic, we started running into all sorts of issues with either disk space filling up before our workers were able to push notice details to S3, or even worse, an application instance failing completely thus losing any unprocessed details. In those rare cases, another application instance would be automatically provisioned, and the XML on that filesystem would be lost.
In order to display exception details quickly, we decided to make use of MongoDB, removing temporary file system and S3 storage alltogether. When an exception hits our API, we do the same processing we’ve always done but store it in a MongoDB collection instead. The three main advantages to you are:
- Error details are always available, immediately after we receive them. Therefore you can click on the error URL that you receive on the notification emails and start seeing details for the error with no delay.
- A more robust storage approach, where app instance failures will never cause details to be completely lost. With careful planning, disk space is not an issue either.
- Better response times: A nice by-product of this change has been that both storing and reading the data has improved the response time of the application by roughly 30%.
We can’t stop here. We have encountered numerous problems with our current environment, and we are working to improve our infrastructure. This has been our primary focus for the last couple of months.
We plan on migrating our application to a more traditional hosting environment. While we will continue to use virtualization for application servers and other utilities, our databases will now run on bare metal. We are confident that this will increase our overall performance even more, and provide a predictable path for growth. Among other things, this solves:
- The bad neighbor problem, where other instances in the cloud steal precious CPU cycles. For high traffic applications like Hoptoad the cost of this problem is very real. On our planned setup, our app servers will run under our own hypervisor, so it is impossible for other applications to steal our CPU.
- I/O contingency - while most apps can run just fine on the cloud, it is underprovisioned for an application like Hoptoad. We will gain superior I/O bandwidth by designing an infrastructure with faster disks that can support our needs.
We have been forced to focus our efforts on performance improvements and architectural changes that can support the growth we’ve seen. We are very sorry for the bumps on the road along the way. We are also tired of feeling apologetic. Enough is enough. We have made changes to improve your experience as a customer, and we will continue to do so. Please bear with us until we’ve migrated our infrastructure. We’ll keep you updated as to the timeline for the hosting move. We look forward to being able to stop worrying about performance, and start worrying about how to improve the service by providing better features that make more use of the data, and help you handle your app’s bugs efficiently.
FYI: Hoptoad/Airbrake was sold to RackSpace and is now called Airbrake Bug Tracker.